Image Source: Unsplash
When a former staff member leaves a 1-star review for your company, it's best to respond quickly and professionally, even offering to talk further about the situation to understand the root causes. But it's also an opportunity to think about employee awards programs that could've prevented the review.
Awards aren't just about motivating your staff to work harder. They're about fostering psychological safety through strategic recognition, genuine appreciation, and consistency. In turn, a proactive approach to awards can boost sentiment, social proof, and retention, resulting in a stronger employer brand online.
Develop a Strong Company Culture
Often, the root causes of poor employer reviews can be traced back to workplace environments. This is where a strong company culture is invaluable.
In practice, a company culture is a set of principles that unite all staff members. It's a holistic design that considers:
-
Workflows
-
Feedback systems
-
Thoughtful appreciation
-
Awards and rewards
-
Wellness
When employees see leaders and managers model these principles, they're more likely to trust the system. Offering genuine praise also leaves a lasting impression, with one Gallup study citing recognition from managers as the most meaningful among employees at 28%, followed by CEOs at 24%.
Create an Awards Program
Consistency is the glue that ties company cultures together. It helps employees feel visible and encourages them to take more ownership in their roles. A recognition program only works if people can count on it, so anchoring awards to a regular schedule is worth the effort.
The physical awards themselves matter more than they might seem. When they reflect your company's identity, they carry meaning beyond the moment. Quarterly sales standouts might earn something bold and individual, while employees who consistently model company values call for something different in tone. Years-of-service recognition tends to work best when it feels understated but lasting. Sites like Awards.com let you customize awards across a range of formats for your employee recognition program, so you're not stuck with generic options.
To keep the program credible over time, consider appointing a small oversight board to define and revisit award criteria. Building in a peer nomination process also goes a long way. It distributes recognition beyond what managers alone might notice, and gives colleagues a meaningful way to acknowledge each other.
Promote Peer Recognition
According to a paper cited by Science Direct, peer recognition programs encourage coworkers to help each other, strengthening social ties. Digital awards could be really helpful, especially through team collaboration platforms that allow employees to give digital coffees or donuts for a job well done.
These awards are ideal for teamwork recognition, modeling values, and onboarding milestones to welcome new employees. Managers could encourage weekly peer shout-outs, where each employee chooses a new coworker each week to shout out. Even recognizing the little things can go a long way in building a positive work culture, like refilling the water cooler or clearly communicating meeting notes in emails.
Boost Retention and Social Proof
Think about the lasting outcomes of an employee awards program. Improved retention is often the first that springs to mind.
A case study cited by HR Executive found that a company's incentive program led to a 62% drop in employee turnover. The study also points out that employees essentially "save up" for rewards through a strong work ethic. Other notable findings include a staggering 78% reduction in absenteeism and a 70% improvement in employee wellness.
The above stats reflect an engaged workforce that's more likely to act as brand ambassadors. This helps build social proof for your employer brand while reducing the risk of negative reviews. Employees who document company beach clean-ups on Instagram or post about 5-year work anniversaries on Facebook all contribute to social proof.
Inspire Positivity
Counteract negative reviews with proactive recognition programs that inspire positive interactions. Kick-start this mission with a strong company culture. Once you have a foundation, create a consistent awards schedule, peer recognition system, and an engagement strategy that builds positive social proof.
Refine your company ethos and HR protocols with the latest hiring strategies, productivity tips, and more!